No, colostomies are usually not as bad as people fear, but they are not nothing either. A colostomy is surgery that brings part of the large bowel out through the abdomen so stool leaves into a pouch (NHS). For many people the alternative was pain, bleeding, incontinence or a life-threatening bowel problem, and daily life improves. For others there is a real adjustment, with some lasting downsides.
That is the short version of a question that fills r/ostomy every few weeks. The most-upvoted answers in a recent r/ostomy thread on exactly this question describe relief, an adjustment period that felt manageable, and rare stigma. But several commenters in that thread actually have an ileostomy, not a colostomy, and the thread is made of people who are doing well enough to answer it. This guide separates the stomas, lays out what the research shows about quality of life, gives the real complication numbers (including the uncomfortable ones), and explains the colostomy-specific option of irrigation.
What is a colostomy, and how is it different from an ileostomy?
A colostomy brings part of the large bowel (colon) out through an opening in the tummy, called a stoma. An ileostomy brings out the end of the small bowel instead. Both send stool into a pouch, but the output differs, and so do the usual problems. Mixing them up is the biggest source of confusion online.
The NHS describes a colostomy as part of the large bowel brought through an opening in the tummy, usually because part of the large bowel needs to be removed or rested after surgery (NHS). The reasons include bowel cancer, inflammatory bowel disease, diverticulitis or an abscess, a blockage, poor blood supply to the bowel, and injury to the bowel or spinal cord that stops you controlling when you poo (NHS). A healthy stoma should be soft, slippery and pink, like the inside of your mouth, should not hurt, and can bleed easily if scratched or wiped (NHS).
| Colostomy | Ileostomy | |
|---|---|---|
| Part of bowel used | Part of the large bowel (colon) | End of the small bowel (ileum) |
| Output | Stool, often firmer because more colon remains | Liquid or soft, like oatmeal (NHS) |
| Typical pouch | Closed pouch changed after a bowel movement, or drainable (Bladder and Bowel Community) | Drainable pouch emptied through the day (Bladder and Bowel Community) |
| Hydration and blockage focus | Hydration is harder to maintain after a colostomy (NHS) | Higher output means more attention to fluids and salts |
If you are comparing your situation with posts online, check which stoma the person has. A person with an ileostomy after colitis surgery is describing a different daily routine from someone with a sigmoid colostomy after rectal surgery. For ileostomy-specific questions see our guides on signs of an ileostomy blockage and how much water to drink with an ileostomy. If you are weighing a stoma against a pouch, J pouch vs stoma covers that decision. Practical clothing tips are in how to tuck an ostomy bag in pants.
What does research say about quality of life with a colostomy?
The evidence does not give a clean yes or no. Some reviews find colostomy lowers quality of life, some find no clear difference from having no stoma, and some find improvement, depending on the person and the alternative. Studies are mostly observational, so they cannot prove the stoma caused the difference.
Here is the spread, which is the honest picture:
| Study | Who | What it found |
|---|---|---|
| Vonk-Klaassen 2016, systematic review of 14 studies | Long-term colostomy patients, mostly after colorectal cancer | All 14 found living with a colostomy affected quality of life negatively. Problems included sexual problems, depressive feelings, gas, constipation, dissatisfaction with appearance, changes in clothing, travel difficulties, tiredness and worry about noises (Vonk-Klaassen 2016) |
| Pachler 2012, Cochrane review of 35 observational studies (5,127 participants) | Rectal cancer surgery with or without permanent colostomy | 14 studies found stoma patients did not have poorer quality of life than those who had sphincter-preserving surgery; the rest found some difference, not always favoring non-stoma patients. The review could not draw firm conclusions (Pachler 2012) |
| Krouse 2009, matched survey (491 responders) | Rectal cancer survivors at least 5 years out | Both men and women with an ostomy had worse social well-being than survivors without one; only women had significantly worse overall and psychological quality of life (Krouse 2009) |
| Waddell 2020, systematic review of 15 studies (488 people with a stoma) | Spinal cord injury | 9 of 11 studies reporting quality of life found it improved with a stoma, two found no difference. Time spent on bowel care fell from more than an hour to under 15 minutes a day in the studies measuring it (Waddell 2020) |
Read those together and a pattern emerges. When the stoma replaces something that was working reasonably well (a sphincter-saving rectal operation), the comparison is close or slightly unfavorable. When it replaces something that was not working (severe bowel dysfunction after spinal injury), the stoma often wins. Most of the harshest data come from cancer survivors, who are dealing with cancer treatment on top of the stoma, so their scores are not a pure measure of the colostomy.
That matches what many people in r/ostomy say: the stoma is better than what came before. It does not match everyone. Women in the Krouse survey reported more overall and psychological difficulty, and the Vonk-Klaassen review is a reminder that sex, body image, gas, clothing and travel are common sore spots. A fair summary is "often livable, sometimes better, sometimes harder than people let on".
We found no good study of quality of life after colostomy specifically in people with Crohn's disease or ulcerative colitis. Most colostomy research is in cancer, diverticular disease, spinal injury or incontinence, and IBD surgery more often involves an ileostomy or a pouch. If your question is about colitis surgery, read life after colectomy for ulcerative colitis and how do you know if you need a colectomy, and ask your surgical team for IBD-specific data.
How long does it take to adjust to a colostomy?
Most evidence suggests the hardest stretch is the first few months, with improvement over the first year. A Japanese study found quality of life lowest at 2 months after surgery and close to pre-surgery levels by 12 months, except social functioning. Adjustment is individual, and skill with pouch care matters a lot.
In that study of people with a permanent colostomy after rectal cancer surgery, scores at 2 months were lower than before surgery, and by 12 months most had returned almost to their pre-surgery level, with social functioning the exception (Ito 2012). Treat that as one small preliminary study of cancer patients, not a universal timetable. The NHS gives a physical timeline: it usually takes around 8 weeks to recover and return to usual activities, with no heavy lifting or strenuous activity during that time while the tummy muscles heal (NHS).
What predicts a good adjustment? In a study of 51 people with a colostomy surveyed 6 months after surgery, stoma care self-efficacy (confidence in managing the stoma) explained 57.5% of the variation in adjustment, with acceptance, relationships and stoma location adding more (Simmons 2007). In plain terms, the person who feels competent changing and emptying the pouch tends to adjust better. A narrative review of 37 studies named modifiable factors that can improve quality of life: exercise, preoperative stoma site marking, family support, maintaining social networks, education, spirituality and financial stability (Alenezi 2021).
That is practical. It points to things you can ask for:
- Stoma site marking before planned surgery. A WOCN and ASCRS position statement says marking the site in advance enhances the likelihood of independence in stoma care, predictable wear times and returning to normal activities (Salvadalena 2015). In emergencies this is not always possible.
- Teaching before surgery. A 2025 meta-analysis found preoperative stoma education roughly halved skin complications (9.5% versus 19.4% in two studies, risk ratio 0.45), though it found no clear difference in other outcomes and not enough data on quality of life (Shi 2025).
- Hands-on practice with your stoma nurse before you go home. Our guides to how to empty an ostomy bag and how often to change an ostomy bag cover the two skills people worry about most.
What are the most common colostomy complications, and how often do they happen?
The two most common are parastomal hernia and peristomal skin problems. A systematic review of 18 randomized trials found stoma complications ranged from 2.9% to 81.1% depending on the trial, with end colostomy having the highest rate of the stoma types studied (Malik 2018). The spread is wide because definitions and follow-up differ.
That huge range is not a typo. A systematic review of 21 prospective studies reached the same frustration: complication rates varied widely even for the same problem, because of different study durations, missing definitions and inconsistent measurement (Salvadalena 2008). So treat every percentage below as a ballpark, not a prediction for you.
| Complication | What it is | Reported rate | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Parastomal hernia | Bulge beside the stoma where bowel pushes through the abdominal wall | 4.0 to 48.1% of end colostomies; 0 to 30.8% of loop colostomies (Carne 2003) | Rates rise with CT scanning and longer follow-up |
| Peristomal skin complications | Redness, soreness or breakdown of skin under the wafer | 36.1% of colostomy patients within 90 days, versus 47.5% for ileostomy (Taneja 2019) | US cohort of 168 patients |
| Prolapse | Stoma sticks out further than it should | No reliable rate found | Usually managed by stoma nurses; surgery if it causes problems (Maeda 2022) |
| Retraction | Stoma sinks back below skin level | No reliable rate found | Different bags and accessories can help (NHS) |
| Blockage and dehydration | Reduced or no output; fluid loss | Not quantified here | Can be urgent; see red flags below (NHS) |
How common is a hernia after a colostomy?
Parastomal hernia is the complication people are most likely to meet over the long term with an end colostomy. A literature review put it at 4.0 to 48.1% of end colostomies and 0 to 30.8% of loop colostomies (Carne 2003). Studies that look harder find more. In 75 people with an end colostomy, a hernia was found on examination in 44% and on CT in 47%, and 60.8% had one by either method (Moreno-Matias 2009). Of the hernias found on examination, 82% were symptomatic in that study.
A prospective audit of 90 people found an overall hernia rate of 33%, higher after sigmoid colostomy than ileostomy (45.9% versus 22%). For each extra millimeter of stoma aperture the hernia risk rose by 10%, and for each additional year of age by 4% (Pilgrim 2010). Those are associations from one audit, not a recipe you can act on yourself.
Can surgery prevent it? The trials disagree. A Norwegian trial found hernia in 2 of 32 people who got mesh at the time of colostomy and 12 of 26 who did not (Lambrecht 2015), but the larger Swedish STOMAMESH trial of 232 people found no difference in hernia rate at 1 year and concluded prophylactic mesh could not be recommended (Odensten 2019). If hernia is a worry, ask your surgeon what they do and why.
Many hernias are small and manageable. The NHS says swelling around the stoma may be managed by your stoma nurse or with surgery (NHS). A review of repair techniques found in 2003 that mesh repair had lower recurrence than direct tissue repair (0 to 33.3% versus 46 to 100%) (Carne 2003). Ask about support belts and hernia-friendly pouch fits as well.
How common are skin problems and prolapse?
Skin problems are common, especially early. In a US health-system cohort of 168 people, 36.3% had a peristomal skin complication within 90 days of surgery: 36.1% of colostomy patients, 47.5% of ileostomy patients and 15.0% of urinary diversion patients (Taneja 2019). Those with skin complications were more likely to be readmitted to hospital. This is a retrospective record review, so it counts what was documented.
Most skin problems come from leaks, an ill-fitting wafer or adhesive. The practical fix is a well-fitting system, regular measuring of the stoma, and nurse review. Our post on how often to change an ostomy bag explains the warning signs, such as itching or burning, that mean change now.
Prolapse and retraction have no well-established rates in the sources we could verify. What we can say is that a prolapse can usually be managed conservatively by stoma care nurses, with surgery considered if it interferes with care or causes obstruction (Maeda 2022), and that the NHS notes different bags and accessories can help with both prolapse and retraction (NHS). The wider review of ostomy complications also lists bleeding, necrosis, stenosis and dehydration from high output (Murken 2019).
Can you control a colostomy with irrigation?
Some people can. Colostomy irrigation means flushing the colon with water through the stoma at a set time, so the bowel empties on a schedule. An evidence report found it reduces how often the bowel empties, cuts pouch use and can reduce gas and odor. It suits only certain colostomies and needs training.
The evidence report (Kent 2015) reviewed four studies of people with sigmoid or descending colostomies. It found irrigation reduced the frequency of bowel evacuations compared with spontaneous evacuation into a pouch, reduced pouch use, and often led to 24 hours or longer without output, so some people could stop using a pouch day to day. People who irrigated reported less flatus and odor (Kent 2015). One study found higher disease-specific quality of life with irrigation, but not on a general quality-of-life measure. A small Turkish study of 25 people who irrigated and 10 who did not found irrigation was safe and may help quality of life, though both groups improved after stoma nurse counseling (Karadag 2005).
Limits to be clear about:
- It is mainly for left-sided (sigmoid or descending) end colostomies, not ileostomies.
- The studies are small and few, so the evidence is modest.
- It requires teaching by a stoma nurse, regular time (often daily or every other day), and is not right for everyone, so your nurse or surgeon decides whether it fits your bowel and health.
- You should not start without clinical advice. Ask your stoma nurse whether you are a candidate.
If gas, odor and unpredictable output are your main fears, irrigation is a good question to bring to your next stoma clinic visit.
What is daily life really like with a colostomy?
Day to day, most people manage work, clothing, relationships and exercise, with some adjustments. The NHS says stoma bags are well designed, you should be able to wear your usual clothes, you can go back to work when you feel well enough, and you can resume your sex life once you feel ready. The research adds that gas, sex, travel and appearance remain common problems.
Here are the practical areas people ask about, with what the sources support:
- Clothes and body image. The NHS says it is normal to worry about appearance and that you should be able to wear your usual clothes. Talk to your stoma nurse about body image and sex. Dissatisfaction with appearance and change in clothing are listed among colostomy-related problems in the Vonk-Klaassen review (Vonk-Klaassen 2016).
- Sex and relationships. The NHS says that once you feel ready you can continue your sex life as before, and that trying different positions may help if there is discomfort. A colostomy does not affect fertility, but check with your doctor that you have fully recovered before trying to get pregnant (NHS). Sexual problems appear in the research on quality of life, so raising it with your team is normal, not awkward.
- Work. The NHS says you should be able to return to work when you feel well and comfortable looking after your stoma, and to speak to your employer if your job involves heavy lifting. For wider job questions, see best jobs for people with Crohn's disease.
- Food. After surgery you will usually eat low-fiber food while the bowel heals, then reintroduce usual foods and aim for a balanced diet. Some foods cause gas or smell, and eating regularly and chewing well helps prevent blockage (NHS). Our guide on tracking food triggers with an ostomy explains how to test foods one at a time.
- Medicines. The NHS warns that slow-release medicines may not work as well with a colostomy because they can pass straight into the bag, and to ask your doctor about liquid or powder forms. Never stop a prescribed medicine without speaking to your doctor.
- Noise and odor. Worry about noises is among the problems in the research, and gas is another (Vonk-Klaassen 2016). Pouch filters, diet changes and, for some, irrigation can help. Ask your nurse.
- Exercise and travel. Exercise is one of the modifiable factors linked with better quality of life (Alenezi 2021), while travel difficulties show up as a problem in the colostomy research. In the r/ostomy thread, one person who has had a colostomy since childhood described traveling widely, climbing mountains and running marathons. That is one person's story, not a promise, but it shows that a colostomy is compatible with a very active life.
- Cost and supplies. In the UK, the NHS says a permanent colostomy qualifies for free stoma bags on prescription, while with a temporary colostomy you may need to pay (NHS). Supply costs and coverage differ in the US, Canada and Australia, so ask your stoma nurse or insurer.
Is a colostomy permanent?
Not always. A colostomy may be temporary and reversed later, or permanent, depending on why it was needed (NHS). A temporary one is meant to rest or protect the bowel. But "temporary" does not guarantee reversal: after a Hartmann procedure, one review found a mean reversal rate of 44%.
That review pooled 35 studies and 6,249 patients who had Hartmann reversal and put the mean reversal rate at 44%, with the most frequently reported reasons for not reversing being high anesthetic risk (ASA class) and patient refusal. Reversal itself carried risk: overall morbidity ranged from 3% to 50% (mean 16.3%) and mortality from 0% to 7.1% (mean 1%) (van de Wall 2010). Most of the studies were retrospective, and they are older, so surgical practice has changed.
If you have a temporary colostomy, ask the surgeon three things: what would need to be true for reversal, how long they expect to wait, and what the plan is if reversal is not possible. For the ileostomy equivalent, see ileostomy reversal recovery.
What do people in r/ostomy actually say?
The community's most common message is that the stoma was better than the illness, and that stigma was rarer than feared. That is lived experience, and it comes with a bias: people who are doing well tend to answer these threads, while people who are struggling often post separately or not at all.
Themes that came up repeatedly in the thread and others like it:
- "The alternative was worse." Several people describe a stoma as a relief after severe pain or a life-threatening illness. Some who answer are describing an ileostomy after losing the colon.
- "It took getting used to." People describe an adjustment period, noise and the fear of public embarrassment, followed by a sense that it became routine. This lines up with the quality-of-life dip and recovery in the Japanese study, though one thread is not evidence.
- Rare, usually mild stigma. Many describe that comments were uncommon and handled with humor. This matches the finding in research that social well-being and body image are the weak points, so the experience is not universal.
- Outdated fears. Some commenters compare a stoma to other medical aids, such as dentures or prosthetics, arguing that society has moved on.
- Complications are discussed less. Hernias, skin damage and leaks are discussed more in dedicated threads than in "is it that bad" posts. If you only read the cheerful ones, you will under-estimate them.
We do not use any of this as proof that colostomies are good. We use it to show what people say they wish they had known, and to point you to the data above.
What can make the first months easier?
The strongest evidence points to preparation and nurse support: stoma site marking, preoperative education and building confidence with pouch care. Beyond that, practical habits help. These are common-sense steps drawn from the sources above, not medical instructions, so check them with your stoma nurse.
Questions worth taking to your stoma (WOC) nurse:
- Can my stoma site be marked before surgery (if planned), and who will teach me?
- Is my colostomy likely to be temporary or permanent, and why?
- Which pouching system fits my stoma and skin, and how often should I change it? (See how often to change an ostomy bag.)
- Am I a candidate for irrigation?
- What should I do if my skin is sore or the wafer keeps leaking?
- Who do I call out of hours if output stops?
- How do I manage my regular medicines with a colostomy?
- Is there a local or online ostomy support group (for example through Colostomy UK, the United Ostomy Associations of America or a hospital service)?
For the technical skill most people dread, our step-by-step guide to how to empty an ostomy bag walks through it, including public toilets.
Clairop logs meals, symptoms and stool in seconds, then looks for the foods your gut reacts to, including reactions that land days later.
When should you get urgent help with a colostomy?
Get urgent help if you have a very high temperature or feel hot, cold and shivery, lots of blood from the stoma or in the bag, signs of dehydration, severe tummy pain, vomiting (especially green vomit), or no output for much longer than is normal for you. The NHS says these may be signs of infection or obstruction (NHS).
Also call your stoma nurse or doctor promptly, rather than waiting, for:
- Less output than usual, cramps, nausea or swelling around the stoma, which can point to a blockage. The NHS says a blockage is serious because the bowel could rupture.
- A stoma that turns dark, purple or black, which can mean poor blood supply and needs same-day assessment.
- Skin that stays sore, weeping or broken despite a well-fitting wafer.
- A growing bulge, or a stoma that has changed length or position.
- Low mood, anxiety or avoidance of intimacy that does not ease. Mental health is a legitimate part of stoma care, and your nurse or doctor can link you to support.
Can tracking help you decide how it is going?
A simple log can show whether your system fits your life, which is exactly what your stoma nurse needs. Useful things to write down are change dates, how many days each wafer lasted, leaks and what you were doing, skin condition, output pattern, and food or drink that changed gas or smell.
This is where an honest word about tools helps. Clairop is a free-to-download app that logs meals and symptoms for people with IBS, Crohn's or colitis (see how it works). It does not have a field for pouch changes, so keep those in a notes app, and use Clairop to see how foods line up with your output and symptoms. For other options, see our list of apps for Crohn's disease. A log is a conversation starter for your team, not a diagnosis.
So, are colostomies as bad as people say?
Mostly no, with caveats. The strongest honest statements are these. For many people with severe pain, incontinence or life-threatening disease, a colostomy improves life (NHS; Waddell 2020). For people whose bowel could have been kept, the quality-of-life evidence is closer, and some studies show worse outcomes, especially for sex, body image, gas and social well-being (Vonk-Klaassen 2016; Pachler 2012). Complications such as hernia and skin problems are common enough to plan for. And much of how it goes depends on teaching, fit and support, which you can ask for.
This article is general information and not medical advice. It does not replace your surgeon, stoma nurse or doctor.




