A barrier ring is a stretchable collar that fills the gap around your stoma, and ostomy paste is a caulk-like filler for scars and creases. Neither is a glue, and many people with a well-cut wafer use neither. Adhesive removers help skin on the way off, while "adhesive" sprays or wipes are a separate extra for stickiness.
This guide is for people with an ileostomy, colostomy or urostomy who have been handed a bag of accessories and are not sure which, if any, they need. It sorts the products by the problem they solve, shows what the research does and does not say, and ends with what to ask a stoma nurse. Clairop does not rate or sell ostomy products, so there are no rankings here.
How this was put together: we read the manufacturer and charity guidance cited below, searched PubMed and Europe PMC for studies of rings, paste, convexity and adhesive injury, opened each paper we cite, and read the r/ostomy survey thread for the lived-experience side. It has not been reviewed by a clinician, and it cannot replace a stoma (WOC) nurse who can see and feel your stoma.
What is the difference between an ostomy ring, paste and adhesive?
A ring is a flexible, pre-shaped hydrocolloid collar you can cut, stretch or stack. Paste is a tube-squeezed filler that works like caulk. Adhesive can mean a remover for taking the wafer off, or a liquid or wipe that makes it stick harder. Each solves a different problem, and each is optional.
Here is how the products line up, based on a manufacturer's own description and a nursing review.
| Product | What it is for | What it is not | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| Barrier ring (flat or convex) | Fills uneven skin around the stoma so the wafer fits better; can be cut, stretched or stacked; goes on the wafer or on clean, dry skin | Not a cure for a badly sized opening or a stoma that has changed shape | Hollister |
| Barrier extenders or strips | Frame the outer edge of a wafer with extra hydrocolloid adhesive | Not a fix for output creeping in at the stoma | Hollister |
| Paste | Acts as a caulk to fill scars, dips and creases | Not an adhesive; too much may interfere with the seal | Hollister, Burch 2011 |
| Stoma powder | Absorbs moisture on slightly irritated or moist skin so the wafer can stick | Not medicated; stop it when skin has healed, and brush off excess | Hollister |
| Barrier film or wipe | A thin protective layer on skin | Not a filler for gaps | Burch 2011 |
| Adhesive remover | Helps lift the wafer and clear residue while reducing the chance of skin stripping | Not something that makes a wafer stick | Hollister |
| Belt | Supports a convex fit and can add security | Not a substitute for a well-fitting wafer | Hollister |
A nurse-written review in the British Journal of Nursing groups these as accessories to treat, protect or "level" the skin around the stoma. Filler paste, seals and convex appliances, for example, can resolve creases or treat a retracted stoma (Burch 2011). The Bladder and Bowel Community adds a sentence worth keeping in mind: you may be shown adhesive remover sprays, barrier sprays, strips and pastes, but you may not need all of them, because everyone has their own routine (Bladder and Bowel Community).
"Adhesive" is where the confusion starts. In r/ostomy, one person pointed out that adhesive glue is a throwback to the days when appliances had no adhesive of their own, and that a ring is, loosely, the modern version of paste. The question gets muddier because some people use liquid adhesives or sticky wipes on top of a wafer that already has adhesive. We did not find published studies of those products on peristomal skin, so we cannot say how they compare with doing nothing.
Do you actually need a ring, paste or adhesive at all?
Many people do not. In the r/ostomy survey thread that prompted this guide, the most common reply was "none": a well-cut wafer, a change schedule that suits the skin and no extras. Some say a stoma nurse told them "less is best." Others use a ring or paste daily and say they cannot manage without.
The thread (r/ostomy survey) is a snapshot of preferences, not evidence, but the patterns are useful. We describe them without quoting:
- People who use nothing often describe a colostomy with steady output, a precut or carefully cut opening, and frequent changes (some change a one-piece closed bag every day, so the wafer never sits long). A few say they stopped rings and paste because they felt more layers meant more chances for the seal to fail, or for a contact allergy to show up.
- People who use a ring describe it as a buffer between the stoma and the skin, a way to fill gaps when the opening is cut slightly large, or a help for irritated skin. People with very liquid output, retracted stomas or an uneven abdomen are overrepresented here.
- People who use paste mention scars, creases and a stoma sitting in a fold. Some find paste messier than a ring and harder to remove, while others abandoned rings and kept only paste.
- People who stopped rings include some who say rings made leaks more likely, with a few guessing that the ring sits behind the wafer and gives output a path, and one saying handling the ring too much was part of the problem. Others who tried both say the reverse.
- Stomas change. One long reply describes a stoma nurse recommending the fewest products possible, a soft convex bag and a slim seal added only after weight gain changed the abdomen. The same reply notes that stomas change a lot in the first 6 months.
The take-home is the one the Bladder and Bowel Community gives: products are individual, and you may not need them all (Bladder and Bowel Community). A good reason to add a product is a specific, visible problem. A poor reason is "everyone else uses one."
What does the research say about moldable rings and barriers?
Studies of moldable barriers are mostly uncontrolled, but they point the same way: skin often looked better after switching. A 2017 randomized trial of 104 elderly people with colostomies found less irritant dermatitis with a moldable barrier at 1 month, and no difference in how often the barrier was replaced.
Here is what each study actually shows, with its limits.
| Study | Design | Result | Limit |
|---|---|---|---|
| Hoeflok 2009 | Prospective multicenter evaluation, 172 people and 49 nurses | At baseline, skin irritation was noted in 41% of nurse evaluations and by 46% of participants; most rated the moldable barrier very good or excellent | Satisfaction ratings, no control group; the authors call for controlled studies |
| Szewczyk 2014 | Prospective observational study, 561 people from 90 centers | Among people with an existing stoma and skin problems, intact skin rose from 39.5% at baseline to 86.2% after 2 months | No comparison group; people may improve with attention and time; authors say comparative studies are needed |
| Liu 2017 | Randomized, 104 people aged 65 to 79 after colostomy for colorectal cancer | Irritant dermatitis was significantly lower with a moldable barrier (p = .01) and self-care satisfaction was higher; replacement interval did not differ | One month of follow-up, one country, one population |
| Hunt 2018 | Single-arm feasibility study of a novel ring design, 20 people with ileostomy, 12 finished | Skin score improved on average; dropouts were largely due to incompatibility with some convex systems | Tiny, no control group |
| Quigley 2021 | Single-arm study of the same type of ring, 25 people, 20 finished | Seven improved, 11 unchanged, two worse; the trend was not statistically significant | Small, no control group |
| Milne 2025 | Three-case series | The authors report improved self-care and skin health in each case | Three cases |
A few honest readings. The strongest design among these is the randomized trial, and it compared a moldable barrier with a conventional barrier, not a ring with paste or with nothing. The largest studies measure satisfaction and skin change without a control group, so they cannot separate the product from time, nursing attention and the usual ups and downs of peristomal skin. And the two feasibility studies carry a practical flag: some people could not use the ring with certain convex systems, which is a reminder that products interact.
None of this says rings are bad or good. It says a ring is a reasonable, low-risk tool for a defined problem, such as uneven skin or irritation from output reaching the skin, and that nobody has shown it is better than the alternatives for the average person.
When is ostomy paste the right tool?
Paste is mostly for contours a ring cannot follow, such as a scar, a dip or a crease beside the stoma. It is a filler, not a glue. Hollister's guidance says too much paste may interfere with a good seal, so the usual idea is a thin bead where a gap exists and nothing where skin is flat.
The practical points from the sources and from r/ostomy:
- Use it where there is a gap. Burch lists filler paste, seals and convex appliances as options for creases and retraction (Burch 2011). In the survey thread, people who use paste mention scars and a stoma sitting in a crease.
- Less is more. Hollister says paste is not an adhesive and too much can interfere with the seal (Hollister). Several people in the thread say they use a very thin layer, or a single dab in the deepest part of a scar.
- Check the label for alcohol. Retailer listings advertise some pastes as alcohol-free and sting-free, one as low-alcohol and others without such claims, so alcohol content varies by product and the sting question is worth settling on the packaging. Alcohol can sting skin that is raw. This is a product detail to check, not a medical finding.
- Paste can be an allergen for some. A published case describes severe peristomal dermatitis that did not respond to usual treatment; patch testing found allergy to an ingredient in a stoma paste, along with other substances (Scalf 2000). It is one case report and tells us allergy is possible, not common. It also matches what one person in r/ostomy wrote about avoiding extra products because of a history of contact allergies.
- Know it can be messy to remove. Several people in the thread say paste is harder to clean off than a ring, and one says it ended up in the belly button. Ask your nurse how to remove it without pulling the skin.
If paste still leaves a leak, the issue is probably not the paste. A deep or irregular defect around a stoma is something a stoma nurse may handle with convexity, a different baseplate, or occasionally something more involved. One 2026 case study describes a woman with ulcerative colitis and an ileostomy whose recurrent leaks, caused by scarring and concave skin, improved after a hyaluronic acid filler injected into the skin (Heyer 2026). That is a single case and is not advice; it shows that for some stomas, products alone are not enough.
When do you need a convex wafer instead?
A convex wafer curves outward to press on the skin around the stoma, so a flush, retracted or deeply set stoma can protrude slightly into the pouch opening. It addresses stoma position and shape, which rings and paste only partly cover. Convex baseplates are chosen by a stoma nurse, because the depth and firmness that suit one abdomen can be wrong for another.
What the evidence says:
- Expert consensus supports it, including early after surgery. A 2022 consensus of 10 nurses and physicians, built on a scoping review, reached 8 statements about convex pouching systems in the postoperative period and across the first 6 months after stoma creation. The paper notes that controversy remained over using convexity soon after surgery (Colwell 2022).
- A 2026 Nordic consensus reached agreement on 13 statements for using convex baseplates from the early postoperative period, and states that appropriate convexity selection is central to preventing leakage and peristomal skin complications (Stengade 2026).
- Design details matter. A computer simulation of three different abdomen types found that the depth and the location of tension were the most influential features for central tension on the skin, with slope and depth most affecting tension at the edge (Bradley-Clarke 2025). It is a model, not patient data, but it supports a plain point: "convex" is not one thing.
- Convex does not guarantee a seal. In a cross-sectional study of 160 people, 13.8% leaked weekly or more often. Risk factors included a stoma placed in a way that did not meet international guidelines, not having proper knowledge and skills in ostomy care, and having a convex baseplate (Indrebo 2023). That last finding does not show convexity causes leaks. People are usually given convex baseplates because their stomas are harder to fit, so it may be a marker of difficulty. A cross-sectional study cannot separate those explanations.
Hollister also describes convex barrier rings, which add gentle convexity to a flat wafer, and belts that clinicians often add to enhance convexity (Hollister). In r/ostomy, people with a colostomy describe a soft convex bag with a slim seal helping after weight change. These are examples of how people combine tools, not a recipe.
If your stoma is flat, retracted, sitting in a fold, or you have a hernia or soft belly, convexity is a conversation for your stoma nurse, who can feel the abdomen, watch you sit and stand, and choose depth and firmness. See our guide to how often to change an ostomy bag for how fit and wear time interact.
Clairop logs meals, symptoms and stool in seconds, then looks for the foods your gut reacts to, including reactions that land days later.
Which problem needs which product?
Match the product to the specific problem you can see, and change one thing at a time. Uneven skin or scars point to paste or a ring, a flush or retracted stoma points to convexity, sore skin after removal points to a gentler removal routine, and output under the wafer points to checking opening size, fit and change timing first.
This table is a starting map, built from the manufacturer and nursing sources above. It is not a prescription.
| What you see | What people and sources usually try | Ask your nurse about |
|---|---|---|
| Scar, dip or crease next to the stoma | A thin bead of paste or a ring to level the skin (Burch 2011) | Whether a ring, paste or different baseplate suits that contour |
| Stoma flush with the skin, retracted or in a fold | Convex baseplate or convex ring, sometimes with a belt (Hollister, Stengade 2026) | Depth and firmness of convexity, and a plan to re-check as your body changes |
| Output creeping under the wafer at the stoma edge | Check opening size first, then discuss a ring or convexity | Re-measuring the stoma and whether it has changed shape |
| Edges lifting, sweat or movement loosening the wafer | Extenders or strips, belt, or warming the wafer; wafer edges that lift are an adhesion problem, not a gap problem | Whether another baseplate or an accessory suits your skin |
| Red, moist or slightly sore skin | Stoma powder to absorb moisture, then the wafer, and stop when healed (Hollister) | Crusting technique and whether skin needs treatment |
| Skin stripped or sore every time the wafer comes off | Gentler removal, with an adhesive remover and peeling the skin away from the wafer | Whether the barrier, schedule or technique is causing the injury |
| Skin that does not heal, ulcers, or spreading rash | Not a product problem | A prompt review by a stoma nurse or doctor |
The last row matters. Peristomal skin problems can have causes other than leaks. A dermatology review lists contact dermatitis, infection and mechanical trauma, and also conditions linked to systemic disease such as inflammatory bowel disease, pyoderma gangrenosum and psoriasis (Morss-Walton 2021). If you have Crohn's disease or ulcerative colitis and the skin around your stoma breaks down in a way that fits none of the usual patterns, treat that as a medical question.
How do adhesive removers and "adhesive" products fit in?
Removers protect skin when the wafer comes off, while "adhesive" sprays and wipes try to make it stick harder. International consensus groups treat adhesive-related skin injury as a real, preventable contributor to peristomal skin complications, but we found no trials of sticky wipes or sprays against nothing.
Two separate ideas are worth keeping apart.
Removal. A 2019 international consensus defines peristomal medical adhesive-related skin injury (MARSI) as erythema, epidermal stripping or skin tears, erosion, bulla or vesicle seen after an adhesive pouching system is removed. It notes that more than 80% of people with an ostomy will have a stomal or peristomal complication within 2 years, and that a scoping review found little evidence on how common MARSI is or how best to manage it (LeBlanc 2019). A 2024 update from nine experts produced 20 consensus statements on assessing, preventing and managing these injuries (Barton 2024). The hands-on advice that appears in patient guidance is to hold the skin taut, start from the top, and peel the wafer back slowly, using adhesive remover spray (Bladder and Bowel Community). Hollister describes its remover as silicone-based and alcohol-free, with the aim of removing the barrier while reducing the potential for skin stripping (Hollister). That is a manufacturer's description, not a trial result.
Sticking. Liquid adhesives, tacky wipes and barrier films are used by some people in the survey thread to make a wafer or ring hold longer, and several describe these as the thing that finally worked, particularly for rings that kept lifting. They are lived experience, and we found no studies measuring them on peristomal skin.
A practical caution that appears in the thread: if the real problem is output working under the wafer, a stronger outer stick may not address it, and one person argues it can make the underlying issue harder to see.
Residue is another point. Several people say removing leftover barrier before the next change was key, and the Bladder and Bowel Community says to apply rings, sprays or paste only after skin is dry, and to make sure they are completely dry before the new bag goes on (Bladder and Bowel Community).
If you feel stinging, burning or a rash under a new product, take the wafer off, clean the skin with plain water and tell a stoma nurse. Do not try to push through it.
How should you fit and apply the wafer so the extras work?
A good seal starts with the basics: a correctly sized opening, clean and fully dry skin, and warmth and firm pressure for a minute or so. Extras amplify a good fit and rarely rescue a bad one, which is why many nurses start with sizing before adding anything.
A short checklist built from the Bladder and Bowel Community's step-by-step and the sources above:
- Measure and cut to the stoma. Stomas shrink after surgery. UOAA describes the stoma slowly shrinking over about 6 weeks (UOAA), and the Bladder and Bowel Community says it goes down considerably over 2 to 3 months and advises regular measuring (Bladder and Bowel Community). That is why a setup that worked early may need to change.
- Remove the old wafer gently. Hold the skin taut, peel from the top, and use a remover if skin is fragile (Bladder and Bowel Community).
- Clean with warm water and dry well. Pat rather than rub. Residue from lotions, oils and shower products that leave a film can stop a wafer sticking (Bladder and Bowel Community).
- Add the gap-filler only if it is needed. A ring around the stoma or a thin bead of paste, applied to clean, dry skin or to the wafer, and fully dry where the product says so.
- Apply and warm. Roll the wafer on starting from the bottom, smooth out creases and cover it with your hand, since the warmth helps adhesion (Bladder and Bowel Community). In r/ostomy, some people also warm the wafer briefly with a hair dryer or against the body, which is a community tip, not guidance.
- Write down what you used. If a leak happens, you will know what to change.
Peristomal skin care is also moving toward standard routines. A 2026 international protocol from a panel of ostomy experts proposes four steps (cleanse, assess, secure, live) and emphasizes safe cleansing and adhesive removal, repeatable skin assessment with validated tools, and product selection based on anatomy and risk (Beitz 2026). If you shower with your pouch on or off, see our guide to how to shower with an ostomy, and if you wonder about positioning while the wafer sets, read should you lie down after putting on an ostomy bag.
Why does my ostomy leak even with a ring or paste?
Leaks usually come from fit, timing or a stoma that has changed, not from a missing product. Check where output got in, how long the wafer was worn, and whether the opening still matches the stoma. Then change one thing at a time and bring the old wafer to your stoma nurse.
Leakage is common, which can be reassuring and frustrating at once. In a UK cross-sectional study of 114 people within a year of stoma surgery, 43% had leakage onto clothes in the previous two weeks, 85% had some peristomal skin complication, and leakage and skin problems were linked with lower mental wellbeing and quality of life (Brady 2025). A meta-analysis of ten studies reported peristomal skin complications in 15.5% to 47.7% of people, with ostomy type, diabetes, self-care knowledge and chemotherapy among the associated factors, though the included studies were of generally low quality (Ma 2024). A systematic review of 23 studies gave a wider range, 36.3% to 73.4% (D'Ambrosio 2022). Estimates differ because studies define complications differently. What they agree on is that skin trouble is common, which is why nobody should feel they failed for needing help.
A way to read the back of the old wafer:
- Output tracks in around the stoma opening. Suspect opening size, a stoma that changed shape, or a gap. This is where rings, paste and convexity come in, and where a stoma nurse is most useful.
- A leak starts at an outer edge. Suspect adhesion, sweat, movement, hair, residue or a crease. Edges and strips or a belt may be discussed, along with drying and warming.
- The wafer is soft and white and sodden all over. Suspect wear time. Our guide on how often to change an ostomy bag covers published ranges, and ileostomy output being rich in enzymes.
- Leaks come overnight with a ballooning pouch. Gas and filter performance can matter. One person in r/ostomy says a better filter reduced their night leaks more than any accessory. Our guide to how to empty an ostomy bag covers timing, and how to tuck an ostomy bag in pants covers keeping the pouch from dragging on the wafer.
- Leaks began after weight change, a new scar or a bulge near the stoma. Ask about a hernia, new convexity, or a belt.
What to ask a stoma (WOC) nurse
Bring the old wafer, a rough log of how long it lasted and how it failed, and the products you have tried. A stoma nurse can measure your stoma, check your abdomen sitting and standing, and sort the product question into fit, skin or something else.
Questions that tend to be productive:
- Is my stoma flush, retracted or sitting in a fold, and would convexity help?
- Is my opening the right size now, and when should I re-measure?
- Do I need a ring or paste, or would a different baseplate remove the need?
- Which products are likely to be a problem for my skin, given any allergies?
- How should I remove paste and rings without hurting skin?
- What counts as a skin problem I should bring you rather than treat myself?
- Can I have samples to compare one at a time?
Avoid adding several products at once. If a leak stops, you will not know why, and if skin reacts, you will not know what caused it.
When should you get urgent or prompt help?
Seek urgent care for a stoma that changes color, for no output with cramps, vomiting or fever, or for signs of dehydration. See a stoma nurse or doctor promptly for skin that is raw, weeping, painful, blistered or not healing, especially if you have Crohn's disease or ulcerative colitis.
- Urgent: UOAA says a stoma should be red, which means a good blood supply, and that you should contact your surgeon if it turns blue or black or if there is little or no output (UOAA). The UK's NHS says to ask for an urgent doctor's appointment or call a nurse line (NHS 111 in the UK) for a very high temperature, lots of blood from the stoma or in the bag, an ileostomy that is not active for more than 12 hours, or severe cramps with nausea and vomiting (NHS). For blockage signs, see signs of an ileostomy blockage.
- Prompt: the NHS advises contacting your stoma nurse or doctor if you think you have a problem with your stoma or it is causing skin problems, and notes that skin damage can be helped by special products such as sprays or wipes and by measuring your stoma regularly (NHS). Itching or burning under the wafer, a rash that outlines the wafer, or a sore that grows are reasons to remove the wafer and ask.
This article is general information, not personal medical advice, and it cannot tell you which product suits your stoma.
Can tracking help you work out what works?
Yes, but a simple log is enough. Write the date, how long the wafer lasted, what you used, what output was like, where it failed and what the skin looked like. After two or three changes, patterns show up, and your stoma nurse can use the same notes.
A plain notes app, spreadsheet or paper diary is fine for this. If you also want to see how meals and symptoms line up with output changes, Clairop logs meals and symptoms by tap, voice, text or photo, but it has no field for pouch changes or skin products, so keep wafer notes elsewhere. For food-related output changes, see how to track food triggers with an ostomy, and if you are preparing for a nurse or surgeon visit, how to describe stomach pain to a doctor has a useful structure. If you are still deciding between surgeries, J-pouch vs ostomy covers the big picture.
Which myths about ostomy rings and paste should you ignore?
A few ideas come up again and again. Each is partly true in some situations, which is why they last.
- "Paste is glue." Hollister says paste is not an adhesive and that too much may interfere with a good seal (Hollister).
- "A ring always prevents leaks." Evidence for rings is mostly uncontrolled, and people disagree in r/ostomy. For some, rings are the fix, and for others they seem to add a failure point.
- "More products means more protection." Each product is another chance for a reaction, residue or a weak layer. People in the thread who changed one thing at a time were the ones who could say what worked.
- "Convex always means better." Convexity helps some stomas, and comes in many depths. In one study, convex baseplate use was associated with more leakage, probably because it marks harder stomas, but that cannot be settled from the data (Indrebo 2023).
- "Skin pain is part of having a stoma." Peristomal skin complications are common, but they are also a recognized, treatable problem. Persistent soreness is worth a nurse's attention.
- "The fit that worked at first will keep working." Stomas shrink after surgery, and weight and scars change the surface. Re-measure and re-check, especially after a change in weight.
So which should you use: ring, paste or adhesive?
Start with the simplest setup that gives you a leak-free wafer and calm skin: a correctly sized opening, clean, dry skin, a change schedule that fits your output and a warm, firm application. Add a ring or paste only for a visible gap, convexity for a flush or retracted stoma and a remover if removal hurts.
Neither the research nor the community has a single winner. Moldable barriers show promising skin outcomes in small uncontrolled studies and one small randomized trial, convexity has expert consensus behind it for the right stoma, and adhesive products sit largely on lived experience. The best tool is the one your stoma nurse can show works for your body, which is why a quick fit check beats a shopping spree.




