clairop

How Ripe Should a Banana Be for Low FODMAP?

Firm, just-yellow bananas are low FODMAP in a bigger serve; spotty ripe ones are high in fructans and only low in about a third of a banana.

Clairop Team18 min read

Photo: Ahmet Yüksek ✪ / Unsplash

The short answer

For low FODMAP, choose a firm banana that is green-tipped or just yellow. Monash re-tested bananas and rated firm banana low and ripe banana high in fructans, with a small serve of ripe (about a third) still allowed. Publicly reported serves are roughly 95 g firm and 35 to 37 g ripe, so check the app for your current number.

Trying to find your triggers? Clairop logs meals, symptoms and stool in seconds on iPhone, then flags foods your gut reacts to, including delayed reactions.

Get it on the App Store

A banana for a low FODMAP diet should be firm: green at the tips or just turned yellow, with no brown spots. Monash University re-tested bananas and rated a firm banana low in oligo-fructans and a ripe banana high, while noting that a small serve of ripe banana, about a third, is still allowed (Monash FODMAP 2017). FODMAPs are fermentable carbohydrates that some people with IBS absorb poorly.

Is a ripe banana low FODMAP?

A whole ripe banana is not low FODMAP, but a small piece is. Monash's re-test rated ripe banana high in oligo-fructans, then pointed out that the app still gives a small serve of ripe banana, about a third, as acceptable (Monash FODMAP 2017). So the real answer is a number, not a yes or no.

This is where a lot of people get tripped up. A 2017 Monash post announced that bananas had been re-tested because many people reported discomfort after ripe bananas, and the app was updated with the new data. The old picture, in which banana was simply "low FODMAP", stopped being accurate for ripe fruit. A Monash post is an unusually clear public statement, and it is the main source we lean on here, but it gives ratings rather than gram figures.

Gram figures are available second hand. A US gynecologist and IBS author who summarized Monash and FODMAP Friendly data for common (Cavendish-type) bananas reported a Monash low serve of about 37 g for a ripe banana (roughly a third of a large one) and about 95 g for an unripe, green-yellow firm one (Pauls 2025). The same page reports FODMAP Friendly serves of about 88 g for ripe and 150 g for unripe. We cannot see the Monash app's current screen from here, so treat all of these as "as publicly reported" and confirm in the app you use.

A one-third serve is small: 35 g peeled is a few slices, not a whole banana on your cereal. That is why many people on the diet find ripe banana mostly drops out of the elimination phase.

How ripe should a banana be on the low FODMAP diet?

Aim for the early stage: firm flesh, green tips or an evenly pale yellow skin with no brown spotting. That is the stage the publicly reported larger serve of about 95 g applies to. As spots appear and the flesh softens, drop to the roughly one-third ripe serve of about 35 to 37 g.

Ripeness is a continuum, and every list has to draw lines on it. The r/FODMAPS thread that gave this post its question is a ripeness-chart vote, where people picked their favorite stage of a numbered banana picture (r/FODMAPS thread). The pattern in the replies is familiar: many prefer a middle or riper stage for taste, a few like them near-green, and several noted the diet only lets you have the early stages, so some had stopped eating bananas altogether. A few mentioned that half of a mid-stage banana was their compromise, and that very ripe bananas were for baking. That is lived experience, not evidence, but it shows the real problem: the lists use words (firm, ripe) that people apply differently.

Here is a practical stage guide. It is a reading aid built from the public statements above, not a Monash chart.

What you seeReasonable readingReported serve to start from
Green all over or green-tipped, hard to peelFirm / unripeAbout 95 g peeled (Monash, as reported)
Pale yellow, no spots, firmFirm, just ripeAbout 95 g peeled (Monash, as reported)
Yellow with a few freckles, still firmBorderline: treat cautiouslyStart near the ripe serve and test
Spotty or brown, soft, sweet smellRipeAbout 35 to 37 g, a third (Monash, as reported)
Mostly brown, mushyVery ripe (baking stage)No separate public serve found; stay at or below the ripe serve

The middle rows are the honest weak spot. Neither the Monash post nor the reported serve figures describe how to treat "yellow with freckles". The conservative reading is to treat any visible spotting as ripe. The author who compiled the serves says the same about the gap between databases: because ripeness is subjective, lean toward the more conservative, Monash-style portion (Pauls 2025).

For the foundation of the fruit side of the diet, see our low FODMAP fruits list, which puts banana alongside the other fruits and the two sugar problems behind them.

Why does ripening change a banana's fructans?

Ripening is not just softening. It is a chain of chemical changes that moves carbohydrate between forms, and the fermentable chains called fructans and fructo-oligosaccharides (FOS) are one of the things that move. In studies of banana varieties, FOS and sucrose rose during ripening and were higher when fruit ripened in the cold than at ambient temperature.

Be careful about how far that evidence goes. Here is what the papers actually show, and where they stop.

Banana carries fructans, and ripening conditions move them. In a study of seven banana cultivars, Nendran (a cooking banana from India) had the highest fructan content, at about 1433 mg per 100 g, and ripening it at a low temperature (16 °C, 61°F) led to higher accumulation of fructans than warmer ripening (Shalini 2015). This is a different banana from the Cavendish most of us buy, so it shows the mechanism is real for bananas, not what a Cavendish contains at each stage.

Sucrose and FOS build together. In 'Prata' bananas stored at roughly 19 °C (66°F) or 10 °C (50°F), total FOS and sucrose were quantified across ripening, and both were higher in fruit stored at the lower temperature than in the control group. The same paper reports that the enzyme responsible for making FOS in banana looks like an invertase, an enzyme that acts on sucrose (Der Agopian 2009). In plain terms, as sucrose accumulates, small fructose chains start to be built from it.

Green banana is starch-rich. A 2024 review notes that green banana flour is roughly 70% starch on a dry basis, with about 30% resistant starch (Munir 2024). Starch is a different carbohydrate from fructans, and it is not itself a FODMAP, which is part of why firm fruit is better tolerated by the diet's definitions. This review is about flour from green fruit, not about a whole banana you eat, so treat it as background rather than a serve.

Monash gives its own, more modest, reasoning. It says agricultural and environmental factors affect FODMAP levels, that plants tend to accumulate fructans under stress such as cold, and that studies of bananas found fructan content rises when they are stored and ripened in cold storage, now common practice at supermarket chains to guarantee even ripening (Monash FODMAP 2017). It frames this as a possible explanation for the changed results, not as something it proved.

One more practical point follows. If the supermarket ripening conditions matter, two bananas that look identical may differ, and two bananas bought in different seasons or from different stores can behave differently. A single published number is a sample, and even the Australian research behind the first low FODMAP lists describes banana fructans as measurable but not large per 100 g (Muir 2007). That is why the diet works in serves.

Why do firm and ripe bananas get such different serves?

Because the diet rates a serving, not a food. The cutoffs that decide "low" were set from FODMAP levels in typical serves of foods that commonly trigger symptoms, so a firm banana that carries less per gram earns a bigger serve, and a ripe banana that carries more gets a smaller one (Varney 2017).

This is the same logic as for every other low FODMAP food, and it matters for one reason: symptoms scale with dose. In a randomized, double-blind rechallenge trial in 25 people with IBS who had improved on a diet low in free fructose and fructans, symptoms came back in a dose-dependent way for fructose, fructans and both together, and far less for glucose (Shepherd 2008). If the response is dose dependent, then a third of a ripe banana and a whole firm one can both be "safe" while a whole ripe one is not.

Fructans and fructo-oligosaccharides also reach the colon. In a published physiology study, poorly absorbed short-chain carbohydrates increased the water and fermentable substrate delivered to the proximal colon (Barrett 2010). That is the plain mechanism behind gas and bloating, and the reason a bigger serve of fructan matters.

Banana's FODMAP profile is also unusual. The FODMAP in question is mainly fructans, and in a US lab analysis of fresh fruit, firm banana had more glucose than fructose and only a small amount of fructo-oligosaccharide, with no sorbitol or mannitol detected (Chumpitazi 2018). So the usual reasons fruit is high FODMAP, excess fructose and sorbitol, are mostly not the problem here. Banana is a fructan story, and that story is told by ripeness.

Why do Monash and FODMAP Friendly serves differ for banana?

Two groups test different samples and draw ripeness lines in different places, so their numbers differ. As reported, the Monash serves are smaller than FODMAP Friendly's for both ripe and unripe common bananas, and the compiler of those figures puts the gap down to geography, quality, ripeness and averaging (Pauls 2025).

If the gap bothers you, our guide to why FODMAP apps disagree walks through the five checks that explain almost every conflict: serving size, food identity, cutoffs, data date and missing data. Banana is a textbook case of the second check, because "banana" is not one food. It is a ripeness stage, a variety and sometimes a country.

A related caution. The reported FODMAP Friendly figure may include a maximum serve far above what anyone eats. The same source notes that people eat food in the context of a meal, so a high maximum can be too much if you also eat other fructan foods (Pauls 2025). Which brings us to stacking.

Can I stack a banana with other fruit and fructan foods?

You can, but the serves are not additive-proof. A cutoff belongs to one serve of one food, so a banana plus oats plus wheat toast plus other fruit can deliver more fructan in one sitting than any single item would. Test banana on its own before testing it in a combination.

Banana shows up in the combinations that cause the most confusion, and almost all of them involve fructans from more than one place:

  • Banana on oat oatmeal. Oats carry fructans as well; so the bowl carries two sources.
  • Banana on wheat toast with peanut butter. Wheat bread plus banana is two fructan sources in one hand.
  • A smoothie with banana, berries and juice. Several fruit portions arrive together and fast.
  • Banana pancakes. Wheat flour and banana, and often a ripe banana.

Our guide to FODMAP stacking examples works through twelve such combinations and the physiology behind them, and the idea is simple: keep one fructan source per meal while you are testing, and change one thing at a time. That caution is about testing, not a rule to live by. Once you are stable, you can stop counting.

Our low FODMAP breakfast ideas and low FODMAP snacks show how people fit a measured banana into a day.

Clairop logs meals, symptoms and stool in seconds, then looks for the foods your gut reacts to, including reactions that land days later.

Download on the App Store

Are green bananas low FODMAP?

Firm bananas with green tips are covered by the low serve, and Monash's re-test is the reason to prefer them. Whether a completely green banana has a separate entry, we could not verify, so treat it as the firmest end of the range and test it yourself. Green fruit is also starchier, which some people find harder to digest in other ways.

A thread in r/ibs about which fruits people tolerate describes choosing green bananas during diarrhea and riper ones during constipation (r/ibs thread). That is a lived-experience strategy, not tested advice, but it highlights a separate issue from FODMAPs: banana ripeness also changes texture and starch. A banana that suits your FODMAP limit does not have to suit your bowel habit, and the reverse. Do not choose a banana for your bowels on the basis of this post. If bowel habit is the main problem, the practical decision is one for you and your dietitian.

Are dried bananas, banana chips and frozen bananas low FODMAP?

We could not find a publicly verifiable tested serve for dried banana or banana chips, so we will not give you a gram figure. What we can say is mechanical: drying removes water, so the same sugars sit in less weight, and the ripeness of the fruit that was dried is rarely on the packet. Fried chips add an oil and often sugar, which does not help the question.

Treat these as unknowns rather than as safe because "it is just banana". If you want to include them, test a small amount after the elimination phase, with a packet that lists only banana, in the way our guide to low FODMAP reintroduction describes.

Frozen banana is a more straightforward case. Freezing holds the fruit at the ripeness it had when frozen, so the matching serve is the firm or ripe one for that moment. A little-known tip from an Australian dietitian site is to freeze peeled chunks before the fruit goes over-ripe (A Little Bit Yummy), which keeps a firm serve available for smoothies. We found no public Monash statement that freezing itself changes FODMAP content, so treat the stage of ripeness at freezing as what counts.

What about sugar bananas, plantain and banana flour?

Monash has tested more than one banana type, and the type changes the serve. Common (Cavendish-type) bananas are the main supermarket kind; sugar bananas, also called finger or ladyfinger bananas, are small and sweet. An Australian dietitian site reports that Monash lists sugar bananas as low FODMAP in large serves when green or firm yellow, and higher when ripe and spotted (A Little Bit Yummy). Because that is a second-hand summary, check the app before relying on it.

For plantain and banana flour, we did not find public data we could verify, so the honest answer is "unknown, check the product and the app". Banana flour made from green bananas is starch-rich (Munir 2024), but that review is not a FODMAP test, so a starch fact does not make a flour low FODMAP.

How do I test my own banana tolerance?

Test it as a small experiment: one ripeness, one weighed serve, away from other fruit and fructan foods, repeated a few times, with symptoms logged over the next day. A single banana on a single day tells you very little, because gut sensitivity moves week to week.

Reintroduction is built for this. A low FODMAP review describes the diet as three stages: restriction, reintroduction and personalization, with the point being to find what you can tolerate (Whelan 2018). A separate paper on the rechallenge phase describes how foods are re-introduced to establish personal tolerance (Tuck 2017). Banana is a good rechallenge food because you can control the stage and the serve.

A simple plan:

  1. Pick a ripeness and stick to it. Choose one stage from the table above and use the same stage each time.
  2. Weigh the peeled fruit. Peeled weight, because peel is a big fraction of a whole banana. A kitchen scale takes ten seconds.
  3. Start at the reported ripe serve if the fruit is spotted, or the firm serve if it is firm, and keep other fructan foods out of that meal.
  4. Log what follows over the next day: bloating, gas, pain, stool. Note the ripeness and the weight alongside it.
  5. Step up one serve at a time, a few days apart, only if the last step went well.
  6. Stop and rest if symptoms flare, and talk to a dietitian before changing the pattern.

A paper log works. A symptom tracker such as Clairop can hold the meal and what followed, which helps when you want to look back across weeks rather than rely on memory; it is free to download and iPhone only, and it does not diagnose or treat anything.

Your result may not match the list. That is not a failure of the test. The lists are population-level averages from tested samples, and the Monash post itself says that if you currently tolerate ripe bananas well, you do not need to remove them (Monash FODMAP 2017).

Is a low FODMAP diet meant to be permanent?

No. The diet is a short, structured process, ideally with a dietitian, that ends in reintroduction and a personalized diet. Cutting out ripe banana for good because a list says "high" would defeat the purpose of the later phases, where foods are brought back to find your own limits.

A trial of the diet in IBS reduced symptoms compared with a typical Australian diet in a randomized crossover trial (Halmos 2014). That finding supports the diet as a short tool, not a lifelong rule for every fruit. If you are worried about food restriction or have stopped eating many foods, see a dietitian.

What are the common myths about bananas and FODMAP?

"Bananas are low FODMAP, full stop." This was true of the older single entry. Monash's re-test changed that for ripe fruit, so the ripeness stage matters.

"Ripe bananas are banned." They are high in a whole serve, but a small serve, about a third, is still low, and Monash says there is no need to remove ripe bananas you tolerate well.

"Green banana is automatically better for everyone." It is lower in fructans at the serve level, but it is also starchier, and a good FODMAP fit is not the same as a good fit for your bowel habit or comfort.

"All lists agree." They do not, and for banana the ripeness definition alone can account for the gap.

"Freezing or drying makes banana safe." Freezing holds the stage. Drying concentrates sugars in less weight and has no public tested serve that we could verify.

When should I see a doctor?

See a doctor promptly if you notice blood in your stool, unexplained weight loss, fever, symptoms that wake you at night, signs of anemia, symptoms starting after age 50, or a family history of bowel cancer or inflammatory bowel disease. These are not explained by banana ripeness and should be checked first, before you spend weeks on a restrictive diet.

Ask your doctor or a dietitian trained in the low FODMAP diet before cutting out fruit, especially if you are losing weight, have a low appetite, or are drifting toward eating fewer and fewer foods. A dietitian can also help you read the app serves, set up reintroduction, and decide whether a banana is worth testing at all.

The short version

Choose firm bananas, green at the tips or just yellow, for the larger publicly reported serve of about 95 g. Treat spotty bananas as the small serve of about 35 to 37 g, a third. Confirm the numbers in the current Monash app, because Monash updates them. Keep one fructan source per test meal, and let your own logged results overrule the list.

  1. Stage: firm and just-yellow, not spotted.
  2. Serve: weigh the peeled fruit.
  3. Context: one fructan source per meal while testing.
  4. Unknowns: dried, chipped, flour and baked banana have no verified serve here.
  5. You: if you tolerate ripe banana, Monash says you do not have to give it up.

For a fruit-by-fruit comparison, see our low FODMAP fruits list. If a number you read still conflicts with another list, read why FODMAP apps disagree, and if a meal that looks low FODMAP still hurts, FODMAP stacking examples is the place to look. For tool options, our page on low FODMAP apps compares them.

Frequently asked questions

How ripe should a banana be for low FODMAP?
Firm, with green tips or just turned yellow and no brown spots. Monash University re-tested bananas and rated firm banana low in fructans and ripe banana high, while noting a small serve of ripe banana, about a third, is still allowed. Publicly reported serves are roughly 95 g firm and 35 to 37 g ripe, but check the app because serves are updated.
Is a ripe banana high FODMAP?
At a whole-banana serve, yes. Monash's re-test rated a ripe banana high in oligo-fructans, but it also showed a small serve, about one third of a banana, is still low. Monash adds that if you already tolerate ripe bananas well there is no need to remove them, because the diet only needs to be as strict as your symptoms require.
Are green bananas low FODMAP?
Firm, green-tipped or just-yellow bananas are rated low FODMAP at a larger serve than ripe ones, publicly reported at about 95 g in the Monash app. Fully green bananas are not a separate entry in what we could verify, so treat very green fruit as the firm end of the range and test your own tolerance. Green banana is also starchier.
Why does ripening change the FODMAP content of a banana?
Ripening is an active chemical change, and fructans and related fructo-oligosaccharides are part of it. Studies on banana cultivars found sucrose and fructo-oligosaccharide levels rise during ripening, and higher when fruit ripens in the cold. Monash suggests cold storage and ripening practices may be one reason its re-test found ripe bananas higher in fructans than before.
Are dried bananas or banana chips low FODMAP?
We could not find a publicly verifiable low FODMAP serve for dried banana or banana chips, so we do not give one. Drying removes water, so the same sugars sit in less weight, and the ripeness of the fruit used is usually unknown. If you want to test them, treat them as an unknown and try a small amount outside the elimination phase.
Are frozen bananas low FODMAP?
Freezing holds a banana at the ripeness it had when frozen, so the serve that applies is the one for that ripeness stage. A firm banana frozen early keeps a firm banana's serve; one frozen when spotty is a ripe banana. We found no public Monash data on whether freezing itself changes FODMAP content, so freeze at the stage you want to eat.
How much banana can I have on a low FODMAP diet?
Publicly reported Monash serves are about 95 g peeled for a firm banana and about 35 to 37 g, roughly a third, for a ripe one. Another certified list, FODMAP Friendly, has been reported with more generous numbers, so lists differ. Weigh the peeled fruit with a kitchen scale, check the current app, and count other fruit eaten that day.
Can I eat a banana every day on low FODMAP?
A firm banana at the listed serve can fit a daily plan for many people, but the rating is for one serving, not a daily allowance. If you add other fruit, oats or wheat in the same meal, the fructans can add up. A dietitian can help you set a pattern, and a food and symptom log shows whether a daily banana suits you.
What is the best way to find out if a ripe banana bothers my IBS?
Test it in a structured way: eat the same ripeness and weighed serve a few times, away from other fruit and fructan foods, and log symptoms over the next day. Clairop is a free-to-download iPhone symptom tracker that can record the meal and what followed. A dietitian can guide the testing, especially during reintroduction.
Is banana low FODMAP in a smoothie or banana bread?
Only if the serve per person is small enough. Banana bread and smoothies often use very ripe, spotty bananas, which are the high end, and a loaf or a blend can put several bananas into one portion. Divide the banana weight by the number of slices or glasses and compare it with the ripe serve of roughly 35 to 37 g.
What is the best low FODMAP banana to buy?
Buy bananas that are still firm and slightly green at the tips, then use them within a day or two of turning yellow. Bananas keep ripening on your counter, so a bunch bought green gives you several days at the firm stage. If you want fruit at different stages, buy two bunches a few days apart or freeze peeled pieces early.

Sources

  1. Monash FODMAP. Update: Bananas re-tested! Monash University FODMAP blog. 2017. http://www.monashfodmap.com/blog/update-bananas-re-tested/
  2. Pauls R. Dr. Rachel's FODMAP facts: are bananas low-FODMAP? Dr. Rachel Pauls (gynaecologist and IBS author). 2025. https://rachelpaulsfood.com/dr-rachels-fodmap-facts-are-bananas-low-fodmap/
  3. Shalini R, Antony U. Fructan distribution in banana cultivars and effect of ripening and processing on Nendran banana. J Food Sci Technol. 2015;52(12):8244-51. doi:10.1007/s13197-015-1927-8
  4. Der Agopian RG, Purgatto E, Cordenunsi BR, Lajolo FM. Synthesis of fructooligosaccharides in banana 'Prata' and its relation to invertase activity and sucrose accumulation. J Agric Food Chem. 2009;57(22):10765-71. doi:10.1021/jf902163f
  5. Muir JG, Shepherd SJ, Rosella O, Rose R, Barrett JS, Gibson PR. Fructan and free fructose content of common Australian vegetables and fruit. J Agric Food Chem. 2007;55(16):6619-27. doi:10.1021/jf070623x
  6. Muir JG, Rose R, Rosella O, Liels K, Barrett JS, Shepherd SJ, et al. Measurement of short-chain carbohydrates in common Australian vegetables and fruits by high-performance liquid chromatography (HPLC). J Agric Food Chem. 2009;57(2):554-65. doi:10.1021/jf802700e
  7. Chumpitazi BP, Lim J, McMeans AR, Shulman RJ, Hamaker BR. Evaluation of FODMAP carbohydrates content in selected foods in the United States. J Pediatr. 2018;199:252-255. doi:10.1016/j.jpeds.2018.03.038
  8. Munir H, Alam H, Nadeem MT, Almalki RS, Arshad MS, Suleria HAR. Green banana resistant starch: a promising potential as functional ingredient against certain maladies. Food Sci Nutr. 2024;12(6):3787-805. doi:10.1002/fsn3.4063
  9. Varney J, Barrett J, Scarlata K, Catsos P, Gibson PR, Muir JG. FODMAPs: food composition, defining cutoff values and international application. J Gastroenterol Hepatol. 2017;32 Suppl 1:53-61. doi:10.1111/jgh.13698
  10. Shepherd SJ, Parker FC, Muir JG, Gibson PR. Dietary triggers of abdominal symptoms in patients with irritable bowel syndrome: randomized placebo-controlled evidence. Clin Gastroenterol Hepatol. 2008;6(7):765-71. doi:10.1016/j.cgh.2008.02.058
  11. Halmos EP, Power VA, Shepherd SJ, Gibson PR, Muir JG. A diet low in FODMAPs reduces symptoms of irritable bowel syndrome. Gastroenterology. 2014;146(1):67-75.e5. doi:10.1053/j.gastro.2013.09.046
  12. Whelan K, Martin LD, Staudacher HM, Lomer MCE. The low FODMAP diet in the management of irritable bowel syndrome: an evidence-based review of FODMAP restriction, reintroduction and personalisation in clinical practice. J Hum Nutr Diet. 2018;31(2):239-55. doi:10.1111/jhn.12530
  13. Tuck C, Barrett J. Re-challenging FODMAPs: the low FODMAP diet phase two. J Gastroenterol Hepatol. 2017;32 Suppl 1:11-15. doi:10.1111/jgh.13687
  14. Barrett JS, Gearry RB, Muir JG, Irving PM, Rose R, Rosella O, et al. Dietary poorly absorbed, short-chain carbohydrates increase delivery of water and fermentable substrates to the proximal colon. Aliment Pharmacol Ther. 2010;31(8):874-82. doi:10.1111/j.1365-2036.2010.04237.x

Clairop is a general wellness app for people living with a diagnosed digestive condition. It does not replace professional medical care, diagnosis, or treatment. Always follow your healthcare provider's advice.

Clairop logs meals, symptoms and stool in seconds, then looks for the foods your gut reacts to, including reactions that land days later.

Download on the App Store

Apps for this, ranked

Free tools